Every marketer has worked on a campaign that didn’t deliver what was expected.
Perhaps engagement was lower than usual, the leads didn’t materialise or the campaign generated activity without producing meaningful results.
It can be tempting to change everything at once or move quickly onto the next idea. But an underperforming campaign can provide some of the most useful insight into your audience, channels and wider marketing strategy.
Return to the original objective
Start by revisiting what the campaign was supposed to achieve.
Was the goal to build awareness, generate leads, increase sales or encourage repeat purchases?
A campaign can appear unsuccessful when it is being judged against the wrong measure. Strong engagement means little if the objective was to generate qualified enquiries. Equally, a brand awareness campaign shouldn’t necessarily be assessed solely on immediate sales.
Before making changes, check that the objective was clear, realistic and measured using the right indicators.
Look beyond one disappointing metric
One figure rarely tells the full story.
If conversions were low, look at what happened earlier in the customer journey:
Did the campaign reach the right audience?
Were people engaging with the content?
Did they click through?
What happened when they reached the website?
At what point did they lose interest?
This can help establish whether the problem sits with the audience, message, channel, creative or customer journey.
Make considered changes
When results are disappointing, the instinct can be to rewrite the copy, change the creative, adjust the targeting and increase the budget simultaneously.
Even if performance improves, you won’t know which change made the difference.
Where possible, test one meaningful element at a time. This could mean trying a new headline, refining the audience or simplifying the call to action.
Sometimes a campaign needs more time or a relatively small adjustment. In other cases, the evidence may suggest that the remaining budget would be better used elsewhere.
Stopping a campaign doesn’t automatically mean it has failed. Recognising that something isn’t working and changing direction can demonstrate sound commercial judgement.
Record what you learned
An unsuccessful campaign becomes far less valuable if the learning disappears when it ends.
Record what happened, which changes were made and how they affected performance. The insight could influence future briefs, budgets, messaging or channel choices.
It could also become a strong example to use in an interview.
Employers don’t expect every marketing campaign to deliver record-breaking results. They’re often just as interested in how you respond when things don’t go to plan.
Being able to explain what went wrong, how you identified the problem and what you did next can reveal far more than discussing a campaign that worked perfectly from the beginning.
The result might not be your biggest marketing success, but the decisions you made and the lessons you took from it could still provide one of the strongest examples of your ability.
Turning the experience into your next opportunity
An underperforming campaign can provide valuable evidence of your judgement, adaptability and problem-solving skills.
Our guide to seven marketing interview examples worth preparing includes more situations that can help you demonstrate your experience confidently.
If you’re considering your next career move, you can also explore our latest marketing, digital, creative and communications jobs.
Photo by 1981 Digital on Unsplash